I tried both 3.5" and 4" on stock, slightly modded and heavily modded. The 3.5" outperformed the 4" in every scenario. Plus, due to the torque of these engines with the 6spd., the 4" "WILL" hit and rattle at various times such as hard launches and tight turns. This is just my observations with my truck. The 4" seemed to make my already terrible low end lag even worse, no matter what mod I made. I also have a friend running a 4" DP on his regular cab wihtout any of the problems I experienced. I guess his truck does not flex near as much as mine and is auto. His engine also seems to like the 4" alot. I know this info doesn't really answer your question as to which is better, but if you want the 4", try it and live with the effects whether good or bad, or change it to 3.5" DP. It's almost hit or miss, but as a rule of thumb, the 4" makes low end very sluggish.