Dear NYB,
Yes. From the looks of the internals of the transmission, the broken "mechnical diode" (a 1 way clutch) could have been replaced. The transmission, was still good. But the transmission needed to be R & R'd to do this. So I went ahead with the total rebuild. Now keep in mind that this 2001 Excursion has had an easy life with very little towing and never chipped. Also Florida is very flat so the transmission never gets the kind of severe duty use that most others transmissions endure.
To answer your question, yes I stayed with the original valve body because I did not want the hard shifts I had experienced in a friends built motor, built transmission truck.
The transmission after the rebuild feels almost identical under moderate acceleration. But more connected. Feels like a manual, in each gear. With a heavy foot, it shifts more firmly than with the factory 4R100. It also short shifts 1st to 2nd gear with a heavy foot. Do not remember if the stock transmission did this. But I do like the short shift from 1st to 2nd. Instead of winding out 1st gear with no load on, it hooks up in second gear way before red line and pulls hard. (for a stock 7.3 PSD engine)
Yes, 50k on the rebuilt 4r100 and have drained the Mobil 1 AFT 2 times. Looked and smelled like it just came out of the bottle.
I have no way of knowing how much the new transmission affects the shifts compared to the low stall triple disk Suncoast converter. ( I did buy the low stall version)
Just a great combo it seems.
The converter was very expensive, I recall. Maybe about $1500 to $1600 dollars. A new Ford converter was I think about $400. but I may be wrong about pricing of the Ford converter.
Yes, I would do the exact thing again as far as the rebuild goes. Could not be happier. Ask me again in a few hundred thousand miles. Now I am at about 228 k. Truck runs much better than new in every respect. Also made other handling improvements like Michelin rubber, Bilstein shocks, Bilstein steering stabilizer and Hellwig big sway bar kit for the rear axle. I wish I had made these all of the above changes from the start when I bought the truck new in 2001.
Wishing a Great Day to all ! Cannot wait to get in my truck this morning! Still excited about this truck after all these years. Even prefer to drive it over my Z06 vette. (sold) When it came time to get rid of one of the vehicles, I did not even have to think about it. Vette gone and 2001 PSD Excursion in daily use. No regrets.